The use of Artificial Intelligence (AI) in the legal profession continues to attract considerable attention, particularly when it comes to preparing documents for court proceedings.
The Civil Justice Council (CJC) has now published its report on the use of AI in the preparation of court documents, setting out recommendations for how the technology should be approached within the civil justice system.
Rather than imposing strict restrictions or attempting to prohibit particular AI tools, the report adopts a more measured approach. It recognises the potential benefits of AI while acknowledging the risks that can arise if the technology is used inappropriately.
There are five particularly important areas highlighted in the report.
1. A Practical, Risk-Based Approach to AI
One of the main themes running throughout the report is the need for a proportionate and flexible approach to AI.
The CJC does not support a blanket ban on particular types of AI or specific products. Instead, it believes that any controls should focus on how the technology is being used and the potential consequences of that use.
This means looking at the function AI performs, rather than simply identifying the software involved.
Particular attention should be given to situations where AI creates or materially influences the content of documents submitted to the court. Restrictions should be considered where there is a genuine risk to the proper administration of justice, rather than applying unnecessary limitations across the board.
This approach should also allow the legal system to adapt as AI technology continues to develop.
2. Protecting Litigants in Person
Although the original consultation concentrated largely on solicitors and barristers, the report identifies an important issue concerning litigants in person.
Legal professionals are already subject to regulatory requirements, professional standards and duties to the court. Where AI is used incorrectly, existing professional rules can provide a means of addressing that conduct.
However, individuals representing themselves in court may not have the same understanding of legal responsibilities or the limitations of AI-generated information.
There is therefore a concern that the misuse of AI could create additional difficulties in proceedings involving litigants in person.
The CJC recommends that this issue should be given urgent consideration by both the Civil Justice Council and the Civil Procedure Rules Committee.
3. The Importance of Legal Regulators
Legal regulators, including the Solicitors Regulation Authority (SRA) and the Bar Standards Board (BSB), are expected to play an important part in ensuring that AI is used responsibly.
The report recognises that regulators are well placed to provide practical guidance to legal professionals as technology develops. Guidance can often be updated more quickly than formal court rules, allowing the profession to respond to emerging risks.
Alongside this, the CJC envisages a Practice Direction which would bring together and clarify existing principles governing the use of AI in legal proceedings.
It will be interesting to see how these two approaches work together, particularly in balancing professional guidance with formal procedural requirements.
4. AI and the Disclosure Process
AI is already playing an increasingly significant role in large-scale disclosure exercises, particularly when dealing with substantial volumes of electronic documents.
Technology-assisted review and other AI-supported processes can help legal teams identify relevant material more efficiently and manage complex disclosure obligations.
Importantly, the report does not recommend any specific changes to the existing disclosure framework.
This suggests that the current approach is considered sufficiently flexible to accommodate technological developments. It also demonstrates how existing court procedures can evolve alongside new working practices without necessarily requiring extensive reform.
5. Witness and Expert Evidence: Where Greater Caution Is Needed
Perhaps the most significant concerns identified in the report relate to the use of AI when preparing evidence for court proceedings.
The CJC considers that particular safeguards are necessary to protect the reliability and integrity of witness evidence.
It recommends that witnesses of fact should be required to provide a specific declaration confirming that AI has not generated or influenced the substantive content of their evidence.
A different approach is proposed for expert evidence. Where AI has influenced the substantive content of an expert report, there should be appropriate transparency about its use.
These recommendations reflect the importance of ensuring that evidence presented to the court genuinely represents the witness's own account or the expert's professional opinion.
Looking Ahead: What Does This Mean for the Legal Profession?
The CJC's report represents an important step in considering how the legal system should respond to the increasing use of AI.
Rather than resisting technological change, the recommendations seek to recognise its potential while ensuring that appropriate safeguards remain in place.
The report also coincides with the retirement of Sir Geoffrey Vos as Master of the Rolls and Chairman of the Civil Justice Council. He has been a prominent supporter of innovation and the use of technology to improve the administration of justice.
His forward-thinking approach has helped shape discussions about how the civil justice system can modernise while maintaining the standards expected by the courts.
The challenge now will be turning the report's recommendations into practical measures that protect the integrity of legal proceedings without preventing the profession from benefiting from technological advances.
The message is clear: AI has an important role to play in the future of civil litigation, but its use must be responsible, transparent and consistent with the fundamental principles of justice.
You can access the full Civil Justice Council (CJC) report here:
Civil Justice Council – The Use of AI for the Preparation of Court Documents (October 2026)
